Rent vs Buy Instrument for Kids
Should you rent or buy your child's first instrument? Complete analysis of costs, benefits, and when each makes sense.
Quick Answer:
Rent for instruments that will be outgrown (violin for young children) or when testing interest. Buy when you're confident in commitment and the instrument won't need sizing changes (guitar, piano, most band instruments for older students).
| Factor | Rent | Buy |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront Cost | Low ($20-50/month) * | Higher ($100-500+) |
| Long-term Cost | Higher if extended | Lower if kept 2+ years * |
| Size Changes | Easy exchanges * | Must sell/rebuy |
| Testing Interest | Low risk to quit * | Money at risk |
| Quality Level | Standard student | Choose any quality * |
| Maintenance | Usually included * | Your responsibility |
| Ownership | Never own it | Yours to keep/sell * |
| Rent-to-Own | Often available * | N/A |
* Indicates better option for that factor
When to Rent
Renting makes sense when: your child is young and will outgrow the instrument (violin, cello); you're testing interest in a new instrument; commitment level is uncertain; maintenance is included in rental; rent-to-own option lets you keep if they stick with it.
When to Buy
Buying makes sense when: the instrument won't be outgrown (guitar, piano, band instruments for older students); you're confident in your child's commitment; you want to choose the specific model/quality; long-term cost matters (buying is cheaper if kept 2+ years).
Break-Even Analysis
Typically, rental costs equal purchase price in 12-24 months. If your child will use the instrument longer than the break-even point, buying is more economical. If uncertain about commitment or sizing, rent for the first year.
Our Verdict
Rent for the first semester or year to test commitment, especially for strings (violin, cello). Buy if you're confident in long-term use or the instrument won't need size changes.
Shop Both Options
Related Comparisons
Frequently Asked Questions
How long until renting costs more than buying?
Typically 12-24 months, depending on the instrument. A $100 instrument at $25/month rental breaks even in 4 months. A $500 instrument at $35/month breaks even in about 14 months.
What about rent-to-own programs?
Rent-to-own lets rental payments apply toward purchase. This can be a good middle ground - you get the benefits of renting while building equity. Check the terms carefully; some aren't favorable.
Should I rent or buy a guitar for my child?
Usually buy. Guitars don't have size changes as frequent as violins, quality beginner guitars are affordable ($80-$150), and you can resell if needed. Renting guitars is less common.
Still not sure which is right for your child?
Take our quick quiz to get a personalized recommendation based on your child's unique situation.
Take the Free QuizFree, no email required