Piano vs Guitar: Which Is Better for Kids?
The two most popular first instruments compared. Find out which is right for your child.
Quick Comparison
- Piano: Better for music theory, no tuning, visual learning
- Guitar: More portable, plays pop songs, cool factor
- Easier to start: Piano (immediate sound, no finger pain)
- More affordable: Guitar (quality starts ~$100 vs ~$200 for keyboard)
This is one of the most common questions parents ask: "Should my child learn piano or guitar?" Both are excellent choices, but they have different strengths. Let's break it down.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | Piano/Keyboard | Guitar |
|---|---|---|
| Learning Curve | Easier start - press key, get sound | Harder start - fingers hurt at first |
| Music Theory | Excellent - visual layout teaches theory | Good - but less intuitive |
| Portability | Limited (except small keyboards) | Excellent - take anywhere |
| Cost to Start | $100-250 for quality keyboard | $80-150 for quality guitar |
| Tuning Required | No | Yes (regularly) |
| Space Needed | Moderate (need stand/bench) | Minimal |
| Quiet Practice | Yes (headphones) | Limited |
| Singing Along | Possible but harder | Natural and common |
Choose Piano/Keyboard If...
- Your child is visual learner who likes patterns
- You live in an apartment (headphone practice)
- They're interested in classical music
- You want a strong foundation in music theory
- Your child is under 6 (less finger strength needed)
- They don't like finger discomfort
See our keyboard recommendations →
Choose Guitar If...
- Your child wants to play pop/rock songs they hear on the radio
- They want to sing while playing
- Portability matters (camping, friends' houses)
- They're social and want to jam with friends
- Budget is tight (guitars are slightly cheaper to start)
- Your child thinks guitar is "cool"
See our guitar recommendations →
The "Cool Factor"
Let's be honest: motivation matters. If your child dreams of being a rock star with a guitar, forcing them into piano lessons may backfire. Conversely, if they love the idea of sitting at a grand piano, guitar might not inspire them.
The best instrument is the one they want to practice.
Can They Learn Both?
Absolutely! Many musicians play multiple instruments. In fact, piano skills transfer well to other instruments because of the music theory foundation. However, we recommend starting with one instrument and adding others after they've built basic competency (usually 1-2 years).
Our Recommendation
For most children under 8: Start with keyboard. The visual layout, lack of finger pain, and headphone option make it ideal for young learners.
For children 8+ who love pop/rock music: Guitar may be more motivating. The ability to play favorite songs keeps them engaged.
Bottom line: Follow your child's interest. Both are excellent first instruments.
Still Not Sure?
Take our quiz to get a personalized recommendation based on your child's age, interests, and your situation.
Take the Free QuizFree, no email required