Instrument reviews

Quick picks: budget, top pick and step-up

Best budgetMahalo Rainbow Series Soprano UkuleleA low-cost ukulele, the easiest tier on the difficulty chartCheck price on Amazon
Top pickYamaha PSR-E383 61-Key Portable Keyboard61 touch-sensitive keys; no tuning and headphone-friendlyCheck price on Amazon
Step-upYamaha FG830 Solid Top Folk GuitarA solid-top acoustic for a teen or adult who keeps goingCheck price on Amazon

22 reviews of single instruments. A comparison page helps while you are still choosing a category; these are for after you have chosen, when what you want is a reason not to buy. Each one names the weakness that matters, and several of them argue for renting instead.

Written from published manufacturer specifications and the consensus of verified owner reviews. We have not played these instruments ourselves and do not claim to have, and we publish no ratings of our own because we have nothing to base one on.

Pianos and keyboards

Band instruments

Guitars and strings

Drums

Gift guides

Before you buy anything

For a first year student on a band instrument, renting is usually the cheaper and lower risk route, and most reviews here say so. Run the numbers for your own local rates in the rent versus buy calculator, and read the school band guide before ordering anything a director has an opinion about.

What a beginner needs with a first instrument

The instrument is only the start. These are the extras most beginners end up buying in the first month.

TunerSnark SN5X Clip-On Chromatic TunerWorks on guitar, bass, violin and moreCheck price on Amazon
MetronomeKorg MA-2 Digital MetronomeBuilds steady timing from day oneCheck price on Amazon